Whispers Forum

The appellant sought the details of employees appointed under the Reserved Quota in the Assistant Grade-III cadre in the Food Corporation of India in a specific proforma. The PIO denied the information adding that an information shall ordinarily be provided in the form in which it is sought unless it would disproportionately divert the resources of the public authority or would be detrimental to the safety or preservation of the record in question. Before the CIC, the Respondent submitted that the appellant sought information about SC/ST/OBC employees in Assistant Grade III Cadre from 2021 to 2024 along with their verified caste certificates in a tabular format given by him. The respondent submitted that there are around 6000 employees in their department and the compilation of the sought information in desired format for 24 years would disproportionately divert the resources of the public authority. The respondent submitted that in view of the aforesaid reasons, they have denied the sought information U/s 7(9) of the RTI Act. During the hearing, the respondent additionally pleaded that the caste certificates of the employees are exempted U/s 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act. On being asked by the CIC whether the PIO confirms for placing on record his plea for exemption U/s 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act as the same was not earlier mentioned in reply as per record, the PIO confirmed. The CIC observed that the respondent gave an appropriate reply to the appellant. Further, the CIC observed that the respondent had pleaded additional grounds during the hearing and the same was held as appropriate.
Comments
The caste details of an employee are his personal information which are not liable for disclosure. Information can be provided in the format in which it is available and asking the data in a specified format may lead to rejection of RTI application.
Citation: Yashwant Rao Hedau v. Food Corporation of India, File No: CIC/FCIND/A/2024/640832; Date of Decision: 23-01-2026
Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is an accomplished Right to Information (RTI) consultant who has worked for organisations such as IIM Indore, IIM Mumbai, IIM Visakhapatnam and ICAI. She is the co-author of two widely acclaimed books, PIO's Guide to RTI and Right to Information – Law and Practice. She conducts training programmes, workshops, and capacity-building sessions on the RTI Act. She also provides consultancy services on RTI implementation, compliance, and third-party audits. Her weekly article is been published on this website since 2008. Other articles and publications can be accessed on the RTI Foundation website at: www.rtifoundationofindia.com

We the Nationalist people of India stand strongly with Gyanesh Kumar...We support Gyanesh Kumar...We support our Nationalist
Government..
Ashish Rawat

IT cell backed page
Literally no one other than your IT-Cell backed page is doing all these speculations.
Atindriya Chakrabarty

Communist new address is Congress
All communists nowadays join the congress party
D Mehta

A wise understanding for Hindus Protesting all over the country under various banners should deeply understand that the existence of Hinduism is more important today & only the ruling BJP can control this sensitive issue. We have seen in the past decade the upliftment of Hinduism in our country, many examples can be drawn including the making of multiple Mandir Corridors, Jagrans & Jamming sessions on Indian culture all over the country. Today Major countries of the world are under threat of Conversion & they don’t have any way out to save their religion & values. This is the time to stay united & save the country from hidden enemies. Government should create a ministry for resolving all issues related to Protest & Demonstrations by Gen-Z.

Vivek Dhawan

90 percent of bureaucrats are corrupt. And most who defend have allegations against them.

Mradul Ashok

Election machinery

How dumb does one have to be to defend the election machinery when what is being criticized is the way people were removed from electoral rolls. What use are these robust safeguards of when the electoral rolls themselves are allegedly rigged? Idk what these bureaucrats want, are they not satisfied with everything they sucked from the common man while in service that they have to do this now to suck more?

Vivek

Protests are part of the normal democratic process. Delhi being the Capital of the country, there will be frequent protests. The existing place Jantar Mantar is not only small but is surrounded by busy commercial establishments and offices

I suggest the National Stadium near India Gate would be a suitable place for protests. It is an enclosed space and crowd management would be easy. It is near Parliament House and a delegation of protestors can go easily to meet /hand over their grievances to the Government.

Government should consider this option.

S. Gopal

Just wait for another month. The scamgressis, SP and AAP would be at loggerheads with each other. If Pappu manages to get popular, he would obviously demand more UP seats. Maybe even break off the UP alliance. And WRT Punjab, AAP wouldn't want to lose the elections against Scamgressis. So where's the UNITY? Each of them have their own personal agendas. So the question isn't about BJP but about scoring their own brownie points for the elections ahead. Abh samjha?
A visitor
AI in the IT department?
What will happen if manpower in the Income Tax department is replaced by AI on a large scale? Automated processes and AI might well be a game changer.
Vijay Kumar