All three honourable ministers are the best performing & biggest asset to the Government.
Sunil Gupta
India — Major Global Parameters With Low Rankings
1 - Environmental Performance Index — Overall environmental health, climate, pollution and ecosystems — 176/177
2 - Air Quality — Population exposure to air pollution — 175/177
3 - Environmental Health — Environmental conditions affecting human health — 174/177
4 - Biodiversity & Habitat — Protection of biodiversity and natural habitats — 174/177
5 - Press Freedom — Media freedom, independence and safety of journalists — 157/180
6 - Human Development Index (HDI) — Health, education and standard of living — 130/193
7 - Global Gender Gap Index — Economic, educational, health and political gender parity — 131/148
8 - Global Hunger Index — Hunger, undernutrition, child wasting and stunting — 102/123
9 - Gender Inequality Index — Gender disparities in health, empowerment and labour participation — 102/172
10 - Global Peace Index — Societal safety, conflict and militarisation — 127/163
11 - World Happiness Report — Self-reported life satisfaction and wellbeing — 116/147
12 - Rule of Law Index — Fundamental rights, justice, government accountability and corruption — 86/143
13 - Corruption Perceptions Index — Perceived public-sector corruption — 91/182
14 - SDG Index — Overall progress towards the UN Sustainable Development Goals — 94/169
15 - Freedom in the World — Political rights and civil liberties — 62/100; Partly Free
16 - Internet Freedom — Online freedom, access and digital rights — 51/100; Partly Free
17 - Sanitation & Drinking Water — Access and environmental health — 141/177
18 - Waste Management — Waste collection, treatment and disposal — 141/177
19 - Species Protection — Protection of threatened species — 173/177
20 - Ozone Exposure — Population exposure and health burden from ozone — 173/177
Guru G

Can repetition of an RTI application be a ground of refusal?

The Appellant sought details of income of Appellant’s estranged spouse. The Respondent stated that information has been initially denied to the Appellant under Section 8 (1)(j) of the RTI Act on receipt of objection letter from the third party under Section 11 of the RTI Act. However, upon receipt of hearing notice from the CIC, a revised reply as per RTI Act giving numeric figures of income sought has already been given to the appellant. The CIC noted that after initial denial of information under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, the Respondent furnished a revised reply to the Appellant. During the hearing, it was also observed that similar Second Appeals of the Appellant was earlier heard and disposed of by the Commission bearing case File No. CIC/MP/A/2016/001539 dated 12.01.2017, CIC/LICOI/A/2019/162743 dated 10.08.2021 and CIC/LICOI/A/2023/148347 dated 16.04.2025. The CIC has been ordering relief in cases where the applicant’s spouse alleges marital discord and seeks information i.e. gross and net taxable income of their spouse in pursuance of a case pending for maintenance and the Respondent has already shared the generic details of income of Appellant’s estranged spouse vide written submission which is in the spirit of the RTI Act. The CIC held that once an RTI application is answered, the appellants shall refrain themselves from filing another RTI application against the public authority as once information is received and held by them or posted in public domain, because such information is deemed to have ceased to be 'held' by the public authority. Repetition shall be grounds for refusal.
Comments
Seeking the details of the spouse's income is not an uncommon issue in the RTI arena. The CIC has directed for the disclosure of gross income in some cases. In this case, the CIC has spoken out strongly against repeat RTI applications directing that ‘Repetition shall be ground of refusal’ creating a new ground for rejection of information.
Citation: Archana Singh v. LIC of India, CIC/LICOI/A/2024/108893, Date of Decision: 25.08.2025

Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is an accomplished Right to Information (RTI) consultant currently working with the IIM Visakhapatnam. She is the co-author of two widely acclaimed books, PIO's Guide to RTI and Right to Information – Law and Practice. She conducts training programmes, workshops, and capacity-building sessions on the RTI Act. She also provides consultancy services on RTI implementation, compliance, and third-party audits. Her weekly article is being published on this website since 2008 other articles and publications can be accessed on the RTI Foundation website at: www.rtifoundationofindia.com