Whispers Forum

The appellant sought to know from the Office of the Divisional Railway Manager, North Western Railway whether the Assistant Divisional Engineer is competent to authorize the termination of service of a Trackman and other information. Respondent prayed the CIC to grant him time to file written submission enumerating the facts of this case in detail to facilitate due assistance to the bench in disposal of this appeal. The CIC severely admonished the conduct of the Respondent as he did not bother to file written submission despite praying for the same through his representative before the bench. The CIC observed that the Appellant is agitating a matter in which he has already been given a relief by issuing a favourable order despite having indulged in bigamy. The CIC deemed it fit to refer the matter to DRM, North Western Railway to take note of the aberration in the form of lenient view being taken by subordinate officers in such a serious matter as bigamy.
Comments
It is a case where the RTI appeal has taken a spin, or rather a googly. Instead of providing any information, the case may turn into an examination of what the junior officers decided in the case of bigamy.
Citation: Ved Prakash Meena v. Office the Divisional Railway Manager, North Western Railway, CIC/NWRLY/A/2023/139716; Date of Decision : 06.03.2025
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Vishakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books PIO’s Guide to RTI and Right to Information – Law and Practice. Her weekly article is being published since 2008 on this site. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and third party audit to individuals / organisations. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation at the link https://www.rtifoundationofindia.com

Mirror to reality for the first time in India, that is Bharat, a mirror has been shown to the reality: vegetarian buffet @500. The politicians shout the loudest propagating a veg thali @ 5 and another 14. Today, even one roti can’t be bought for 5/14 rupee. Should it cost so much? The mishandling of vegetable, grain, dal edible oil, salt (the single weapon which destroyed the British Empire) prices have robbed the daily wage earner of a nutritious veg thali. In economic terms, it is 800 a day (rich by the PC criterion of 14 in rural and 28 in urban)! For the new avatar feudal “Lords of Poverty” it matters little: most lunches/dinners are thrown by the ministry concerned and it is a routine affair. No grudges, no grievances, no complaints- everybody needs to eat. People can wait till jobs reach the ”satisfaction” level.
M L Gupta

One digital arrest gang is reported to have the sensitive personal bank data of more than 20000 pensioners! It is facilitated by various irresponsible public authorities because of unnecessary exercise like KYC. I have sent a mail to the RBI citing the instance of a mass mailing letter about KYC the SBI had outsourced to some contractor with whom the letter seems to have remained for several weeks before being sent to me through speed post. I am afraid the post man often opens letters and has the audacity to talks about the contents. But the personal data like account number and other details, in connivance with the bank staff, falls in wrong hands and finally reaches the scammers. Can the RBI not stop forthwith this absurd routine and frequent exercise of KYC? Especially in the Digital India and smart phones? If Jeevan Pramanan can be done on phone, why not KYC? It will save crores of rupees in a futile exercise and also spare the account holder the bother of getting the latest photograph done? Are constructive suggestions welcome?
M L Gupta

Selections for the apex level posts in Department of Revenue of Members of CBDT and CBIC may be made soon. There is every need to have strong profiling and background checks preferably by top investigative agencies on the probable, to check corrupt or incompetent officers from manning these positions.
Vijay Kumar
Sunita Williams deserves a ‘Bharat Ratna’
Sunita Williams, the NASA astronaut and an experienced pilot, returned to planet Earth from space after getting trapped for nine months. It was a test of her mental strength and a magnificent feat achieved by a US citizen of Indian descent. She has made India proud. I appeal to the Government to honour her with Bharat Ratna. It would also be a tribute to the US's advancements in the field of space technology.
A K Saxena (Former civil servant)

A consignment booked on March 7, 2025 for delivery in Gurgaon, Haryana is yet to be delivered as on March 18! Website of Indiapost is so slow and awful and it is very difficult to lodge a complaint. It should be able to verify the status using the consignment. Instead it is asking for all kinds of information which it already has. It is not enough to give the pincode of the delivery post office but it is asking for a post office ID without telling how to find it. Since postmen come on bicycles to deliver, the website is also functioning at that speed. It is futile to expect any official to respond to this. It is suggested that the name may be changed to low speed post.
Subramanian