Whispers Forum

Confusion in fixation of pay of Private Secretaries by Ministries / Departments In pursuance of Dept. of Personnel and Training's order No.4/8/2022-CS-II(A), dated 30th June, 2022 services of ad hoc Private Secretaries of CSSS working / posted in various Ministries / Departments were regularized by DOPT and given Select List Year of 2016 and 2017 respectively, according to vacancy position. On the basis of said Order, pay fixation of some of the Private Secretaries, who are far junior in Common Seniority List of 2016 and 2017, has been fixed higher than their senior. This has caused a heart burning among Private Secretaries of CSSS. May I request Department of Personnel and Training to issue appropriate instructions to Ministries / Departments to fix pay judiciously?
H S Chauhan

Why are some civil servants so overrated, when, ultimately, they have to comply with the orders (mostly oral & illegal) of the political masters? The favourite officers succeed in managing best ( read as most sought- after) postings and out-of-turn promotions bypassing the silent majority of officers, who refuse to fall in line. The practice was common during the UPA era, when the Congress supremo was the ‘de facto’ Prime minister. The practice, unfortunately, continues, till date. Is the rating methodology flawed?
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)

Pakistan is hugely affected by the floods aggravating present levels of poverty, hunger and inflation. The Islamic countries, even China, are not coming forward for help. Lip sympathy does not help. India could help Pakistan in these circumstances during the floods and political instability. But, there has to be a request for it. Trade relations were unilaterally suspended by Pakistan, not India. It is high time, Pakistan starts behaving with India and stop cross-border terrorism. Continuance of hostility between the two sub-continental neighbours, will worsen the situation. People of Pakistan are ready for friendship with India. But the army-controlled establishment looks the other way. A referendum in Pakistan will prove this. Pakistani awaam considers itself culturally, historically and linguistically close to India. They welcome free trade relations and visa-free movement of its citizens. But, Pakistan has to move away from hatred to cooperation. Resumption of trade relations will be immensely useful in the normalisation process. Pakistan must amend its Constitution to treat its minorities at par with the majority. Its non-Muslim citizens should be able to occupy key positions. Change from theocracy to secularism is the prerequisite. Why can't a Hindu or Christian be appointed as its President? Why should non-Muslims be called "Kaafirs"? This is irrational and anti- democratic. Pak has been terribly ditched by China due to its single point agenda based on hate-India approach. Pak has to forget China in the face of a fast changing international scenario. This is not wishful thinking. But, all things considered, good-neighbour relations are not possible without democracy taking deep roots in Pakistan, free from military intervention. A Jai Prakash Narayan type anti-corruption movement is missing in Pakistan. This is considered necessary for creating mass awareness and changing its collective attitude towards India.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)

I agree with the views expressed on PFI and whom to blame for this fiasco. Of course this raises many questions too. 1. What were multi-layer so many intelligence agencies doing since 1996. 2. If there are financial dealings of heavy value both with India and from abroad, what was DRI and other financial watch agencies including RBI, banks & Ministry of finance doing, were they in sleep mode, all banks are required to inform MOF & RBI of any fishy or heavy transactions. 3. What were governments doing from 1996 to 2022, were they blind to this serious issue. All the political parties who governed are solely responsible for this & must own responsibility including the present one. But I am positive our system is poor in governance that it dilutes everything by delay & finally the judiciary fails as they can't find evidence which is erased through dilution & delay tactics. As always the story will be dead finally into a grave.
Harish Kumar

The news that the Government is likely to review British influence on the culture, traditions and practices in the armed forces seems to have upset both veterans and serving officers. These traditions and practices were established a couple of centuries ago by the British as per the prevailing context. To claim these will not be changed 75 years after we attained Independence is not a tenable argument. The context has changed considerably and the armed forces will do well to change with the times. My appeal to Servicemen is “to change before you have to. Control your destiny. Otherwise someone will control it." See what happened to Railways and Ordnance factories. Failure to change with times resulted in change being thrust on them. So instead of wailing, seize the initiative, review the continued relevance, suitability and effectiveness of all your practices and introduce changes that are in tune with the ethos of an independent nation, its culture and traditions. Rest assured that if you don't act on your own change will be thrust on you.
Raghavan
Why postings of CITs without consideration of vacancies
Why is the CBDT rushing to post CITs without considering the 57 vacancies created by the recent promotion to the Pr CITs when they have already asked for their posting choices?
Ramesh

Extensions to the officers are bad in policy. Extension creates vested interests.
B K Saha, former Chief Secretary MP
Chief Minister of Rajasthan
Media reports say that Ms. Sonia Gandhi will shortly decide whether Rajasthan will have a new Chief Minister and if so she will nominate the person for this post. It is the constitutional right of the citizens of Rajasthan to choose their Chief Minister through their elected representatives. Is Ms. Gandhi a queen or viceroy or governor general to chief minister of an Indian State? One hopes that MLAs of Rajasthan will show gumption and show the lady where she belongs. How can one allow in independent India an extra-constitutional person, to designate a person as Chief Minister of an Indian state. One hopes that congress MLAs in Rajasthan act to put a stop to this utterly unconstitutional act once and for all.
Raghavan

The National Investigation Agency (NIA) is carrying out massive raids across the country to nab terror modules owned and funded by the Popular Front of India (PFI). Raids are being conducted on a day-to-day basis with religious regularity. On an average, 100 suspects are being captured every day from UP, Bihar, Delhi, Karnataka, Kerala, Punjab, and Maharashtra among others! The security, intelligence and investigation agencies are mandated to protect us from terror modules, sleeper cells having foreign links with ISI., KLF etc. The agencies have done us proud. No other country has possibly launched raids on such massive scales. But, is there any politics behind this? We Indians are fair-minded, experts in analyzing events through the political prism. Let us have a look at the flip side, can we ignore the impact assessment of terror raids on general public? How is it that despite all pre-emptive steps, terrorists continue to be active on Indo-Pak borders? No need to elaborate on daily killings in J&K. One substantive point on common perception. I wish to be upfront. The proud Indian citizens are getting increasingly suspicious about the timing of country-wide raids 24x7 on PFI and their lapdogs. So close to impending elections. The moot point is : How did India's experienced multiple agencies fail to anticipate the threat perception of PFI eight years back in 2014 when the current political dispensation took over? Even the top heavy security paraphernalia headed by a highly professional NSA, failed to see through PFI's gameplan. Why did it wait for the doom at the doorstep? Internal security is closely interlinked with external threats. This grave lapse explains why the terror modules ,even after so many years, are still having a free run in the country besides increasing their populations and vicious anti-national activities. The matter cannot be allowed to rest here. Someone has to own up the responsibility. The laidback bureaucratic pundits in the union Ministry of Home Affairs and the security professionals, have much to explain.
A K Saxena (a former civil servant)