Whispers Forum

The IndiGo fiasco is a live example of what happens when a single company is allowed to have disproportionate power or dominance. IndiGo controls something around 65% of the domestic air-travel market. The problem isn’t only about aviation alone. It could be true for sectors such as telecom, ports, retail, logistics and so on.
When dominance becomes monopoly-like, and regulation/oversight remains weak — that’s when danger begins. Power dynamics tilt when a single firm dominates and public interest gets compromised. Consumers become vulnerable, infrastructure and services become stressful sending shocks ripple widely.
The example of IndiGo is real and immediate and dangerous. The impacts cause systemic disruption, hurting ordinary people and threatening fairness.
No wonder, healthy competition is vital for innovation, better pricing and quality.
What remains to be seen is will the government learn and take necessary steps from the IndiGo pitfalls?
Tyaga Roy

A “did not go airline”, “we, not the ordinary people”, “India’s flying public”, “taxi drivers going hungry for days”, “loss of millions of hours wages for the gig workers”, “price of voters’ choice to weaken a functioning government”, “failed bureaucracy”, “regime change attempts”, “business disruption”, “ causing public inconvenience nonchalantly”, “politicians bargaining for aviation portfolio”, “ bureaucratic hankering for top posts”: end result failures galore! Indigo was no accidental occurrence, it had been brewing for days, yet no preventive measures were taken. Is that how a minister manages the ministry? Is this how a Secretary runs his ministry? Had the airline been monitored rightly, not even an hour’s disruption could have taken place. Unfortunate and ominous!
M L Gupta

Finance Minister announced that Customs is her next target for "Simplification"
Officers have suggested that it must start with divesting powers of Revenue Secretary in Personnel matters of CBIC.
3 posts of Members are lying vacant
A Chief Commissioner is holding charge of DGDRI a post meant for Pr CC!! Reason? No DPC!
Posts of Chief Commissioners are lying vacant because Revenue Secretary was stopped at UPSC gate for 'verification' FM ought have moved to shift both CBIC/CBDT from the Revenue Department.
I wonder when did Ms Nirmala Settharaman last review personnel management of CBIC/CBDT.
I retired years back.
But the Stranglehold on postings by the Revenue Secretary obviously speaks of a "Nexus".
Absolute Power Corrupts!!
Ajay Agnihotri

The present administration at the MoD has done a good job at fostering indigenization, but there is still the problem of integration. The DRDO-developed AIP is yet to be equipped on the Kalvari-class submarines despite being tested, while Pakistan is set to induct 8 AIP-equipped submarines by the end of this decade.
Kishore Anandan
Compulsory physical training for Police Personnel
Police personnel compulsory physical training and pot belly personnel should be placed on compulsory leave without pay until they reduce big bellies. All Police personnel should be physically fit and carry weapons at all times
Srinivasan

‘Die with Zero: Getting all you can from your money and your life’ is a personal finance and life-philosophy book by Bill Perkins. Its main message is ‘Your goal should not be to die with the most money, but to die having lived the fullest life. Let us talk about this concept. The central concept or idea is to use all your resources money to maximize life enjoyment and meaningful experiences rather than saving purely for wealth accumulation or leaving a large inheritance. Do not waste your money that you will not spend in your life time. The book highlights, instead of endlessly saving for the future, Perkins encourages using your money to create meaningful experiences while you are alive, especially when you are young enough to enjoy them. One should maximize life experiences, not one’s bank accounts.
This die with zero school of thought gives you another way of thinking. It says what you got, spend it on life experiences. This concept helps avoid the regret many retirees feel, accumulating wealth only to find that by the time they retire, they no longer have the health or energy to enjoy big life experiences. Hence, do not save it to give to next generation. In today’s world with our life span increasing, by the time we leave the earth our offspring are also in their 50s or 60s. So they are already earning their living and making their own money. You rather spend that money you made on your own and your kids’ life experiences than putting it in the bank.
When you die no matter whatever your bank balances what you really remember and cherish is what you did with your life and how you lived it well. This saving tendency is rampant in as immigrant families and all eastern cultures. We have seen our previous generations in our fathers, mothers, grandfathers, the generation previous to us do it. We got to learn from their mistakes now.
There is a happy balance. Balance saving and spending across your life. I am not saying spend everything or just do not save anything. But there is a very happy balance between saving enough to have a comfortable life till you die and still enjoying life experiences today. You should avoid both extremes that is, over saving meaning having too much money left unused at the end of your life and, overspending, meaning running out of money too early. Convert money into ‘memory dividends’. Experiences pay ‘dividends’ over time because you keep remembering them, gaining joy again. Money is a tool to create memories; health and time are limited, so do not postpone everything for ‘later’.
In conclusion, ‘Die with Zero’ teaches you to spend deliberately, value time more than money and design a life rich in meaningful experiences. The goal is not to be irresponsible but to use your resources wisely so that you do not reach old age realizing you saved too much and lived too little.
Yours truly,
Subbiah Sridhar

I agree, Rajasthan's new CS V Srinivas is very talented. He is so transparent, he uploads his daily work updates on his X account, we the citizens can have a look at the major works which he completes daily.
Although, I wanted the current fertiliser secretary Rajat Kumar Mishra to become Rajasthan's CS, I am also happy with the choice of Mr Srinivas for this post. He is a tech savvy bureaucrat.
Rajat Galav
Staff shortage
When there has been staff shortages in the banks, customers service will definitely receive beatings. We cannot eat the cake and have it too.
Manik

Prime Minister Narendra Modi emphasized the need for "delivery, not drama" in Parliament, urging lawmakers to focus on policy-making and nation-building rather than sloganeering. He stressed that the Winter Session should prioritize discussions on key issues affecting the country, rather than becoming a platform for political point-scoring.
Modi also took a dig at the Opposition, saying they should move beyond their recent electoral defeat and contribute meaningfully to parliamentary debates. He highlighted India's growing global stature, citing the country's economic resilience and democratic strength
Kriti Garg

Search something abt Mr kuldeep khoda IPS....he knows everything about kashmir more way more than these ppl
I Bhatt
Kashmir Affairs
R Swain sahb, S.Sahai sahb. Know the ground, the history, trends.
A Visitor
Kashmir Affairs
Strange to note that no Army pers has found a mention in this narrative.
A Visitor
Kashmir Affairs
What about the CAPF officers who fought the main enemy?
S Sharma