Friday, November 20, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 9 Jun 2026
  Browse by date   All posts2852
  2026207
  2025312
  2024310
  2023309
  2022309
  2021300
  2020312
  2019309
  2018295
  2017189

2026 207 posts · page 7 of 18

Clear filter
Tuesday, 9 June 2026

Gymkhana land

Gymkhana land in Delhi must taken over by the government as Gymkhana club is a place for general public
Virender Madan
Gymkhana land
My view is the acreage registered in their name be given to them. The other part should be taken over. This is main road, closer to institutional area. An engineering or management institute be created there. Even OTHERWISE BJP has not created a single government educational institute for the last 14 years. Purely my view.
Harish Kumar
Exam leak
An exam leak should not just ask for ministers' resignation but also the real people overseeing the exams, but no one can make a govt officer resign! Suspensions and transfers are all temporary!
KK
The NEET CBSE fiasco
Does our country have s law where by a govt officer gets to retain his job even if he as messed up. The neet cbse fiasco is clearly due to inefficiency of the officers st nta and cbse but they have been just transferred
T Tikku
CJP
He should not.. The system is poor not the person.. Bloody Congress and Cockroach will decide now. Shame
A Visitor
All british time clubs be closed
All British time clubs be closed or started afresh by present law of the land
Dr Jag Mohan Singh
Monday, 8 June 2026

How to Resolve the Gymkhana Imbroglio

The Ministry of Urban Development's order to resume land occupied by the Delhi Gymkhana Club has correctly drawn sharp attention to Delhi's chronic deficit in sporting and leisure infrastructure — a deficit that is real and must be addressed. Delhi ranks 141st out of 173 cities on the EIU Global Liveability Index, is the world's most polluted capital, and has only 16 DDA sports complexes for 33 million people — one per 2 million residents, roughly 90 times worse than England's ratio of citizen leisure centres. Singapore has eight times more Olympic pools per resident than Delhi, 17 track and field stadia, and 108 community clubs accessible by public transport. Nations that lead both competitiveness and liveability rankings — Singapore, Switzerland, Denmark — do so precisely because they invest aggressively in parks, community clubs, and sporting complexes. Delhi's ambitions as a global capital cannot be taken seriously without matching infrastructure.
Against this backdrop, shuttering the Gymkhana Club before alternatives exist is a cure worse than the disease. The Club's 27.3 acres house 30 tennis courts, 2 swimming pools, squash courts, a gymnasium, a library, and extensive green grounds — a rare oasis for over 15,000 members, the majority of them elderly retired professionals with a genuine need for accessible sports and leisure facilities. Forced out, they will have nowhere to turn except elite private clubs like DLF, Unitech, and Jaypee (going to be Adani) — whose membership fees run into millions of rupees and are entirely beyond the means of upper-middle-class retirees. The sole beneficiaries of the Gymkhana's closure, in the absence of alternatives, would be precisely those private real-estate and hospitality interests.
The real solution is a bold, large-scale redesign of Delhi's urban fabric to create sporting and leisure infrastructure on a war-footing. DDA's 5,000-acre unused land bank, Cantonment areas, and government properties across Delhi should be unlocked for this purpose. The Lutyens Bungalow Zone — nearly 6,900 acres accommodating merely 950 bungalows at 15 persons per acre — is the most glaring opportunity: redeveloped sensibly, it could yield a secure residential township of 2000 acres for VIPs and 5,000 acres of public commons for parks and a world-class International Sports and Leisure City. This is the kind of transformative intervention that cities like New York (840-acre Central Park) and San Francisco (1,000-acre Golden Gate Park) have made. The Gymkhana debate is an opportune moment for exactly such a course correction — and if abundant, accessible facilities are eventually built across Delhi, even its most devoted members may find they no longer miss the Club.
Raghav Chandra, IAS (retd)
Saturday, 6 June 2026

New Block

Without Congress support these regional parties cannot survive. If they form a third front, BJP will be happy.
Vijoy
INDIA Block
Not possible, they all know that they have lost their ground just because of lack of unity, ignored Rahul Gandhi's warning, instead the INDIA block will become stronger.
NH
Parasite Congress
Need to teach the parasites congress a lesson. Regional parties are far better and less hypocritical than the INC and their leader RAGA.
Navvrat
No formation with Mamata
No opposition block can be formed with Mamata. She's corrupt and has lost all credibility. Her candidate stood 4th in the last By election in Phalta on 24 May, 2026. She and her party are finished. Left will now emerge as the primary opposition in Bengal.
A Minj
Friday, 5 June 2026

Only the Director of Intelligence Bureau is a Four Star officer

Did you know that all the paramilitary forces, CISF CRPF SSB BSF BRO ICG etc all have only DGP rank equivalent... Only the Director of Intelligence Bureau is a Four Star officer .. he wears the pips of a sword and batton , star and Asoka lions (just like the army chief)
Dennis
BJP is looking for strength
BJP is looking for strength as they want 131st constitutional amendment, but rather than inviting people in the party they want them to abstain from voting.
Prem
Thursday, 4 June 2026

Disparity !

CAPF officers of 1993 batch are still serving as DIG, which is 4 ranks below DG. Such disparity !
AK
Don't regret Annamalai
Just don't regret Annamalai, we are with you, always, Good decision indeed, bjp loser, if it doesnt make sense from where you are standing, move away, we love you, wish you happiness always Annamalai is a God in disguise, realise that people of TN and BJP I’ ll stop casting my vote for BJP henceforth
Priy
Mamata Banerjee
Her party is disintegrating superfast - thanks to her and her nephew/son . BJP needs to do nothing
Atul
Overhaul in Congress
"Overhaul" in Congress terminology means replacing one set of sycophants with another, and expecting them to deliver every time using the same assumptions and methodology!
Abhijit
Wednesday, 3 June 2026

Strong and aggressive decision against Nepal

Great going, it's high time to take strong and aggressive decisions against Nepal. As it's run by CIA and ISI
Smita
He will work for the good of BJP as he did in Delhi. Nice man
Rajat
Tuesday, 2 June 2026

Reservation of women in Judiciary

After 75 yrs of independence, we are still talking on reservation. When merit will prevail. In any job merit should be criteria and not caste or sex.
R K Upadhyay
India Bloc
No one will join them ... DMK and AAP will not join congress ... BSP will not join SP ... BRS TRS will not join because of Congress. TMC will not want Congress too ... They are all fighting amongst each other.. Where's the unity ?
A visitor
Monday, 1 June 2026

CBSE Needs Strong Corrective and disciplinary Action , Not a Change of Education Minister

The controversies surrounding CBSE On screen marking have understandably caused concern among students and parents and dented the image of the government at a time when present PM takes personal interest in students welfare by directly interacting with student community on various platforms. However, fixing responsibility and restoring public trust in CBSE is more important than demanding the resignation of the Education Minister, Dharmendra Pradhan, for matters not under his direct control.It would be unfortunate if an effective minister is made to take the responsibility for operational lapses and carelessness of officials within an autonomous examination body like CBSE.Education Minister is not involved in day-to-day functioning, confidential examination processes, or operational decisions. Further ,In today’s governance environment, with close monitoring and transparent appointments by PMO , the scope for ministerial interference in routine functioning is extremely limited.
The more relevant question is whether the officials directly responsible for examination management and CBSE like chairman, controller of examination, secretary and CVO followed established systems and safeguards.Reports suggest that OSM had faced serious difficulties earlier when implemented by UPA government in 2014 but No minister resigned then but OSM was discontinued after public criticism with same problems. If so, was adequate pilot testing conducted by CBSE before rolling it out again at a national scale for Class 12 examinations? Were past experiences and technological risks properly evaluated by above officials of CBSE and the ministry briefed before being implemented?
Technology and reform are necessary, but they must be introduced cautiously, especially in high-stakes examinations affecting millions of students and political risk involved.The lapses in CBSE appear to be carelessness,operational and human failures. Immediate Disciplinary action against top officials or their transfers would send a far more constructive message than politically targeting the minister.
Students deserve both reform and reliability. The focus now should be on restoring trust in CBSE examination systems through accountability, institutional strengthening, and careful implementation of change.
— A Visitor
Saturday, 30 May 2026

Implement 33.33% women quota in judges appointment

SC must look towards themselves and implement 33.33% women quota in judges appointment AND make sure that judges appointed are first generation advocates/jurists..
Pankaj
Congress
The question is will it help the Congress to be more agile and proactive opposition, and counter existing narratives of the current government?
Sukkhu
Friday, 29 May 2026

Whispers Forum — 29 May 2026

Anganwadi workers can become elected public representatives in India under certain conditions. An Anganwadi worker is not considered to hold an "office of profit" under Article 191(1)(a) of the Constitution of India, hence she can contest the election for MLA or Member of Legislative Council (MLC).[1] The Supreme Court of India has also clarified in various judgments that Anganwadi workers are not government employees and do not hold offices of profit, making them eligible to contest elections [1, 2, 3]. However, it is important to note that if elected, they will have to follow the Model Code of Conduct and relevant government rules.
Aditya Kumar
Same 2012 batch CAPF ACs in CRPF are still assistant commandants with no promotion till date, while the same batch IPS officers have gotten 4 promotions to DIGP rank. Wow !
A Visitor
Thursday, 28 May 2026

Post-election situation between Mamata Banerjee/TMC and BJP in West Bengal

1. Election result
BJP won 207 of 294 seats, ending 15 years of TMC rule. Suvendu Adhikari became Chief Minister. Mamata Banerjee lost her own Bhabanipur seat to Suvendu, and even her home ward Kalighat flipped to BJP.
2. TMC’s internal trouble
After the rout, TMC faces reports of defections. Political circles in Delhi and Kolkata are discussing that 8 of TMC’s 10 Rajya Sabha MPs may join BJP, following a pattern seen with AAP earlier. Many TMC MLAs skipped party meetings, and there’s open questioning of Mamata’s leadership after the Bhabanipur loss. CPI(M) leaders say TMC is “melting down faster than ice” and aim to fill the opposition space.
3. Current clashes
- Mamata’s line :She’s aggressively targeting BJP and the Election Commission over the Special Intensive Revision of voter rolls. She’s threatened to bring down the central BJP government if any genuine voter’s name is deleted, and accused BJP of trying to “loot Bengal’s land and erase its identity”.
- BJP’s response: BJP has filed complaints against Mamata for alleged MCC violations and blamed TMC workers for attacks on BJP workers. Suvendu Adhikari has said Mamata is “unfit to hold a constitutional post”.
4. Violence and accusations
Clashes broke out in Shibpur, Howrah right after results. BJP claimed victory came from “unity of Sanatanis,” while TMC accused BJP of using 5-star vehicles and rallies to dominate politics.
5. National angle
Post-election, Mamata has revived calls for opposition unity, saying parties should act like “free birds.” She didn’t rule out a merger with Congress, fueling further speculation.
In short: BJP is in power in Bengal for the first time, TMC is in damage-control mode, and the fight now centers on voter-list revisions, law and order, and political defections.
Aditi
Tuesday, 26 May 2026

NEET exams

PM is setting a bad example in leadership …. In a business or corporate or any system if a person is not performing repeatedly then he is removed. Here he has created more than enough damage to kids' futures!
Girishkj
Incorrect facts
The facts of the case demonstrate that incorrect facts were provided by IOCL, especially as the SDM's certificate was also on records. The CIC is the principal body entrusted with ensuring transparency and accountability. It should take upon itself the verification of the facts. The IOCL vigilance branch should have been directed to examine the facts instead of making the RTI applicant do the work.
Udham Singh